If Eire is available in your area they are a great company. Just ask @Cherokee about Eire insurance. I understand wanting the lowest price but sometimes a little more for much better coverage is worth it.
I found Travelers to have the best rates in my area of NY. My full coverage $1500/ded, no claims, pay in full, is under $1,000/yr. Obviously, there are a number of variables that will change the price. Find a local insurance broker that has connections to several different insurance companies and have them shop the insurance companies for you. They generally know which ones to check first.