Sponsored

Seat Collapse in Accident - Follow Up

PNWMaverick

2.5L Hybrid
Well-known member
Joined
Jan 8, 2022
Threads
5
Messages
618
Reaction score
979
Location
Pacific Northwest
Vehicle(s)
2022 Maverick Hybrid - RIP
Engine
2.5L Hybrid
I'm in total agreement and sympathy with you; but the real demon in this scenario is the person who plowed into you.
Following too close or too fast or distracted, they bear the responsibility in my book.
I had a family member return a new car because it had auto-emergency braking. Their complaint was, "The car keeps hitting the brakes and yelling at me!" Instead of taking that as a hint that they suck at driving they bought a car without it.

These are the people we share the road with.
Sponsored

 

Phimosis

2.0L EcoBoost
Well-known member
First Name
Larry
Joined
Jul 18, 2024
Threads
2
Messages
1,180
Reaction score
1,517
Location
Santa Clarita, CA
Vehicle(s)
2024 Maverick Lariat FX4 4K tow
Engine
2.0L EcoBoost
I appreciate the candor here. It's all perspective, I suppose.

To the other commenter, I'd rather be paralyzed than risk a serious injury to my kid.
Ford Maverick Seat Collapse in Accident - Follow Up IMG_1739


Here’s the image. 46 years old. Average size, like maybe 5’9” and 155 lbs. after the acute inflammation goes down and he gets multiple months of physical therapy, he will probably be able to walk again. He will most likely have some deficits for the rest of his life, like limited dexterity in his hands.

If it’s not immediately clear, this is a side profile (Sagittal) x-ray of a human’s head, neck and shoulders. The dark blob at the bottom are the shoulders. The round thingy at the top is the skull. On the left, you can see the jaw and the teeth inside of the jaw. On the right, you are seeing the occiput, or the back of the head. The lolipop stick in the middle is the spine with a bunch of metallic hardware to hold the fractured bones together. The white circle / oval in the upper left part of the screen is the ear-hole, just like if you were looking into someone’s ear!
 
Last edited:

Bob zimmerman

2.5L Hybrid
Well-known member
First Name
Bob
Joined
Aug 23, 2024
Threads
4
Messages
361
Reaction score
1,141
Location
Northern <MN
Vehicle(s)
25’ Maverick XLT hybrid AWD
Engine
2.5L Hybrid
I honestly have nothing useful to offer in this discussion except: I am grateful the OP is Okay and equally glad his kid was not behind him. But he is Okay and there must be something positive to say about that.

Second, I’m on several forums related to my job and hobbies, this forum being one of them.

I am especially surprised that this forum consistently has users that are courteous and respectful to each other regardless of the conversation. This thread is a difficult one, and some of the replies are from people who, IMO are intelligent and thoughtful in their responses. The rebuttal to them could have been curt and antagonistic but instead was met with respect.

And for that I am also grateful.
Tom
 
OP
OP

Skaht

2.0L EcoBoost
Member
First Name
Scott
Joined
Sep 20, 2022
Threads
2
Messages
16
Reaction score
36
Location
28704
Vehicle(s)
Maverick
Engine
2.0L EcoBoost
At some point in the future your kid will be the driver and I believe you would want that seat to deform and protect their spine.
For sure. That's the crazy thing about being a parent, though. The what-if's now are not the what-if's of later, and you want both.
 

Superg0

2.0L EcoBoost
Well-known member
Joined
Feb 1, 2024
Threads
9
Messages
1,060
Reaction score
1,498
Location
12020
Vehicle(s)
2024 XLT FX4 Azure Gray
Engine
2.0L EcoBoost
I honestly have nothing useful to offer in this discussion except: I am grateful the OP is Okay and equally glad his kid was not behind him. But he is Okay and there must be something positive to say about that.

Second, I’m on several forums related to my job and hobbies, this forum being one of them.

I am especially surprised that this forum consistently has users that are courteous and respectful to each other regardless of the conversation. This thread is a difficult one, and some of the replies are from people who, IMO are intelligent and thoughtful in their responses. The rebuttal to them could have been curt and antagonistic but instead was met with respect.

And for that I am also grateful.
Tom
I agree, the majority of members here are helpful and respectful. This is a good place to learn and enjoy our vehicles.
 

Sponsored

colinl

2.0L EcoBoost
Well-known member
First Name
Colin
Joined
Jun 21, 2022
Threads
32
Messages
5,440
Reaction score
6,175
Location
ICT
Vehicle(s)
'22 Maverick Lariat AWD, '22 Bronco OBX 2-Door
Engine
2.0L EcoBoost
Clubs
 
Phimosis definitely knows more about injuries and law than he does turbocharged engines. :wink: Seriously, that is very helpful commentary and insights.

I doubt the crash test dummies go as high as the OP's body weight (325 I believe he said?) so accidents he is involved in will be outside the bounds of testing for sure, and maybe outside design.

It looks like the seats functioned as designed. There most definitely are incidents of infants being crushed behind a front seat adult whose seat goes rearward in a high-energy collision. But that doesn't mean the alternatives are any better. Vehicles are far safer now than they ever have been, and while we don't like to see Mavericks totaled from (what seems to be) minor rear-end accidents, the rear crumple zones definitely make a huge difference in accidents of this kind of violence.

Unless the OP is competing in world's strongest man or playing the line in the NFL, the best thing he can do for his family isn't buying another vehicle.

Also, I don't see the injury lawyer serving much purpose assuming he and his wife are not seriously injured. You don't get compensation for 'almost' having a life-changing injury. Truck is surely totaled, get a larger one if it makes you feel (or actually be) safer.
 

Bwicka

2.0L EcoBoost
Well-known member
First Name
Brian
Joined
Aug 17, 2023
Threads
19
Messages
883
Reaction score
1,282
Location
Lakeside,ca.
Vehicle(s)
2023 maverick tremor/2023 maverick hybrid lariat
Engine
2.0L EcoBoost
Clubs
 
I appreciate the candor here. It's all perspective, I suppose.

To the other commenter, I'd rather be paralyzed than risk a serious injury to my kid.
I really think at this point for a second row person to be safer and front seats to work as planned , the only solution would be a larger vehicle to offer more space.
Yes you will lose some money on mpg , but if safety is the prime concern for 4 people riding in the vehicle , larger vehicles that get worse mpg are the only real solution at this point .
Its a thin line walking on saving money or safety , one must choose which way to lean.
Glad everyone is ok.
 

Phimosis

2.0L EcoBoost
Well-known member
First Name
Larry
Joined
Jul 18, 2024
Threads
2
Messages
1,180
Reaction score
1,517
Location
Santa Clarita, CA
Vehicle(s)
2024 Maverick Lariat FX4 4K tow
Engine
2.0L EcoBoost
I doubt the crash test dummies go as high as the OP's body weight (325 I believe he said?) so accidents he is involved in will be outside the bounds of testing for sure, and maybe outside design.
I didn’t see where the OP stated he weighs 325 lbs. If that is accurate, then it explains why the seat extended beyond the 35 degrees of rotation safety limit. To me it looks like 40 degrees of rotation (keep in mind that no one sits at 0 degrees of rotation normally, but the seat starts at 15 or so degrees reclined.

The NHTSA uses 6 pediatric dummies and 4 adult dummies. I’ll focus on the adult ones only. First, the smallest one, “small adult female” is 4’11” and 97 lbs. This is the one that is most likely to get injured. The air bags are too powerful for her small size and the seat backs are too stiff for her low weight, so she is more likely to get a spine injury. Then there is the “5th percentile adult female”, which is 4’11” and 108 lbs. Standards get built off of this one, as safety devices are designed for people in the middle, from the 5th percentile to 95th percentile. Then there is the old generation “50th percentile male” that is 5’9” and 160 lbs. And as American’s weight has increased over the years, the new generation 50th percentile male is 5’9” and 171 lbs.

A 325 lb driver weighs 1.9 times as much as the largest test dummy, which means that his drivers seat would have 90% more rotational deformation than with the largest crash test dummy.

Again, I didn’t see where the OP stated his weight, but if it is 325 lbs, this amount of rotational deformation of the seat is completely expected and somewhat unavoidable.

Many lawyers have brought law suits saying that the seat backs allow too much deformation and need to be stiffer, but then the NHTSA scientists get involved and start showing physics data on what happens to the small female and 5th percentile female dummies with the current stiffness requirements. If they go stiffer, it will create more injuries for small occupants.
 

Hot Runr Guy

2.0L EcoBoost
Well-known member
First Name
Terry
Joined
Apr 27, 2021
Threads
98
Messages
4,124
Reaction score
7,571
Location
West Chicago, IL
Vehicle(s)
2024 Edge SEL, 2024 Lariat Tremor
Engine
2.0L EcoBoost
Clubs
 

colinl

2.0L EcoBoost
Well-known member
First Name
Colin
Joined
Jun 21, 2022
Threads
32
Messages
5,440
Reaction score
6,175
Location
ICT
Vehicle(s)
'22 Maverick Lariat AWD, '22 Bronco OBX 2-Door
Engine
2.0L EcoBoost
Clubs
 
Again, I didn’t see where the OP stated his weight, but if it is 325 lbs, this amount of rotational deformation of the seat is completely expected and somewhat unavoidable.
I really think at this point for a second row person to be safer and front seats to work as planned , the only solution would be a larger vehicle to offer more space.
yes to both of these.

F150 seat will still fold like this when the occupant weighs 325, but the rear seat in a supercrew has more than 7" additional rear legroom compared to the maverick which could be critical to mitigating injury.
 
Sponsored

Hot Runr Guy

2.0L EcoBoost
Well-known member
First Name
Terry
Joined
Apr 27, 2021
Threads
98
Messages
4,124
Reaction score
7,571
Location
West Chicago, IL
Vehicle(s)
2024 Edge SEL, 2024 Lariat Tremor
Engine
2.0L EcoBoost
Clubs
 
yes to both of these.

F150 seat will still fold like this when the occupant weighs 325, but the rear seat in a supercrew has more than 7" additional rear legroom compared to the maverick which could be critical to mitigating injury.
The OP has already stated that he'd rather use multiple vehicles than put a backseat passenger at risk, so maybe his vehicle of choice should be a standard cab (no backseat) pickup?

https://shop.ford.com/configure/f15....PYZ...SS6.RCAB.774.]?intcmp=vhp-seconNav-fbc

HRG
 

Phimosis

2.0L EcoBoost
Well-known member
First Name
Larry
Joined
Jul 18, 2024
Threads
2
Messages
1,180
Reaction score
1,517
Location
Santa Clarita, CA
Vehicle(s)
2024 Maverick Lariat FX4 4K tow
Engine
2.0L EcoBoost
The OP has already stated that he'd rather use multiple vehicles than put a backseat passenger at risk, so maybe his vehicle of choice should be a standard cab (no backseat) pickup?

https://shop.ford.com/configure/f150/2024/config/paint/Config[|Ford|F-150 F-150|2024|1|1.|101A.F1K..PYZ...SS6.RCAB.774.]?intcmp=vhp-seconNav-fbc

HRG
Standard cab is worse for injuries from rear impacts. The back wall of the cab prevents the seat from deforming. The deformation is responsible for stretching out the time frame that energy is imparted into the occupants, which lowers their G force load.
 

Old Fart

2.5L Hybrid
Well-known member
First Name
Mark
Joined
Sep 30, 2021
Threads
1
Messages
500
Reaction score
552
Location
Mid Florida
Vehicle(s)
2022 Ford Maverick XLT; 2016 Prius ECO
Engine
2.5L Hybrid
Clubs
 
My 2007 Ford Focus Coupe, which only lasted me 63,000 miles was a POS before I traded it, the drivers seat broke at 18,000 miles, (I admit I was a lard ass at that time, 275# 5-11, yeah yeah I know if I was a foot taller I'd be perfectly round) but I wasn't in an accident just getting into the vehicle so Ford is known for some crappy welds. Dealer wasn't happy about it, I had to drive with 4- 5 gallon buckets behind the seat back for a month. Then the tranny went out twice, the third time it went out I had just picked up the car after they'd supposedly fixed the tranny the second time, I didn't even make it home, turned around and took it back.

Within a week I was driving a Prius.
 

MMDavis

2.5L Hybrid
Active member
First Name
Malcolm
Joined
May 22, 2024
Threads
1
Messages
32
Reaction score
32
Location
SFBay
Vehicle(s)
2024 Ford Maverick
Engine
2.5L Hybrid
Clubs
 
Hey friends. This is a follow-up to my previous post here. I wanted to start a new thread for visibility.

Back story: Owner of a '23 Lariat Tremor. I was on a 2 lane road at a traffic light, waiting to turn left with my signal on and yielding to traffic. Speed limit is 45. My wife was in the passenger seat. We were rear-ended by a Volvo SUV at what was likely the speed limit. The hit was pretty dead on. There were no brake marks and witnesses said there was no indication of braking. Seatbelts were on. Airbags didn't deploy, which seems to be intentional as they wouldn't have done anything.

My seat collapsed fully, and my head rest nearly came off. I went backwards hitting the top/back of my head on the rear seat just below my headrest, breaking the skin. The glossy spot in the below photo is my blood. My wife's seat collapsed, but stopped 2-3 inches short of the rear seat (the photo angle distorts how low it actually was). She was uninjured aside from whiplash.

I've registered a complaint with the NHTSA, as well as located a similar complaint with a '22 that can be found by filtering to "seats." I've not contacted Ford, given their history with this scenario.

I will absolutely never likely won't purchase a Ford again and am actively looking to get rid of my wife's Bronco Sport. My 12 and 20 year old typically ride in the back and the truck was our road trip vehicle. If my 20 year old had been there, their legs would have been crushed and the top of my skull would have gone right into their nose area, causing god knows what kind of damage. My 12 year old would have definitely sustained leg injuries as well. Now we're down a car and having to all ride in a SUV built on the same platform.

This is a known issue, in all vehicles, due to an outdated NHTSA safety standard. You can read about it here and here, and about the act introduced to correct the issue (which I believe has not gone into effect) here. Also a video from CBS here. Wild to think a long-running issue that's killing children isn't a big enough deal for car manufacturers to invest in correcting.


Collision.jpg



Rear.JPG


Seats Down.jpg


Driver Seat 1a.JPG
Dang! That’s a major big deal with the safety rules/laws. I had no idea how dangerous it is to be in the back seat in a rear-ender.
Thanks so much for the information.
 

BeardedMarine

2.0L EcoBoost
Well-known member
First Name
Darrin
Joined
Jul 17, 2024
Threads
20
Messages
491
Reaction score
584
Location
Oklahoma
Vehicle(s)
2023 Ford Maverick
Engine
2.0L EcoBoost
Damn, I hate that this happened and am glad everyone is ok.

I agree about this being a friendly and respectful forum. I think it has to do with the average ages of Maverick drivers.
Sponsored

 
 







Top