Carvana Used Maverick Trade In Values are NUTS!

[CortinaGT]

Carvana offer is $30,600 for my green XLT Hybrid AWD with 4k tow and 15k miles. It was $32,396 new ordered from Grainger in August 2024. Paid about 3k more in registration and sales tax to Ca when I got back with it in Jan 2025.

Sponsored

 

[Surly Old Bill]

I think there is some sort of tax deferral or incentive or something that Carvana takes advantage of.

 

[Mavster Mechanic]

2022 FWD Hybrid XLT w/Lux 65,000 miles offer:

But how long would it take me to get another?

 

[Prickly Pear]

I got an offer for my 24 XLT with Lux package, 2K tow package and Moon Roof, 6K miles - $3850 less than I paid for it, and I'm not including tax and license. In case you think I overpaid, their offer was $6285 below MSRP!
Maybe price varies by location?
Edit, that was last month - they upped their offer $400 - My cup runneth over

 

[Mavster Mechanic]

Carvana is saying the same price as Kelly Blue Book for mine.

 

[MakinDoForNow]

2022 FWD Hybrid XLT w/Lux 65,000 miles offer:

But how long would it take me to get another?

Hmmmmm????
I have a 2022 xlt with luxury pkg with 6900 miles. Would Carvana's buyer appreciate a lower milage one? I'm afraid to ask them

 

[Suzukiridr14]

A few weeks ago prompted by another member I checked and I was being offered $35,600 for my 2025 Lariat AWD Hybrid 4K Tow w/moonroof with 13k miles.

Well today - it has 14,250 miles on it and the Carvana offer increased to $37,200. With it being fully paid off, and I could get most of (90+%) my PremiumCare warranty back...I'm looking at roughly $1,500 for 14 months and 14,000 miles worth of driving.

It is very tempting to sell!!

The reason Carvana offers more then others, is because Mavericks are easy to sell. Carvana makes its money by financing, not by making money on the resale.

 

[Suzukiridr14]

I think the popularity of the Maverick has really increased the Carvana offers just for the heck of it I had then provide me an offer for my 2004 Jeep Wrangler TJ which has had a frame off restoration and was really disappointed with their offer of $2,100 lol not even close

The reason for the low offer, is because Carvana makes their money by financing, they want cars that sell for over 20K and need to be financed.

 

[BlueOval1954]

The reason for the low offer, is because Carvana makes their money by financing, they want cars that sell for over 20K and need to be financed.

Not to mention that the vehicle is 22 yo

 

[Suzukiridr14]

$24,200 for my 2025 XLT. That seems about average and doesn't compel me to go "looking."

I sold 2 cars to Carvana, they are easy to deal with, give you a check on the spot, always pay more then most, because they want you to buy, and finance from them.

 

[Mavtremor24]

Out of curiosity, I looked at my 2023 FX4 with 40k miles, and their offer was… not compelling.

I did the same with my tremor only i got like 63000 on mine.
I almost broke my phone how insulting the offer was

 

[Suzukiridr14]

My Carvana offer is not at all compelling. $23,400 for a 2022 XLT ECO AWD LUX CP360 HPR in mint condition, new tires, 37,000 miles. Replacement cost is a $15,000 difference after shipping, taxes, registration, dealership paperwork. Doesn't compute.

Basically, my Maverick has depreciated almost $5,000 a year compared to new. Yea, I only paid $30,500 for it three years ago. But you have (1) adjust that for inflation, and (2) adjust it for replacement cost. Because if you sell it, what, you're going to walk to work?

I see some of these reported Carvana offers and I scratch my head. I believe that people are getting those offers, but it must a hybrid-only thing, in certain regions.

I mean, I can walk down to my local dealership and buy a great NEW Maverick off the lot for about the same as some of the reported offers I'm seeing.

You don't mention what other offers you got higher then $23400. Remember you paid $30,500 new, so your only losing $7100 over 4 years, most vehicles lose a lot more then that in 1 year!

 

[MakinDoForNow]

The reason Carvana offers more then others, is because Mavericks are easy to sell. Carvana makes its money by financing, not by making money on the resale.

I sold my tremer to carmax that was asking $5 less than they paid me. Don't know what they got but they sold it within one week or so. May have taken a trade in on it. Sales gal said it would be gone quickly when she gave me the check. Two years +/- Ford still sends notices for it's vin#.

 

[Blackbelt]

Carvana offered me $25,300 for my 2024 XL Hybrid with 9K miles. I paid $25,200 for it. Not selling it though. They did give me over $15K for my 2017 Jeep Renegade a few months ago. I sold it to them as that was a great offer.

 

[Glen Baker LLC]

For those folks who will have buyer's remorse. I wonder what carvana will offer for their slate?

Sponsored