Looking at the Carfax it was hit in the rear and suffered enough damaged to be a total write off, has a salvage title. I'd certainly avoid. Very nice price for a Tremor Lariat with just 7600 miles but of course there was a hitch, to good to be true.
I have both as well, my Mav is my everday car, double the gas mileage but if its your toy and my Bronco is mine then the Bronco wins hands down. It's just way more fun and certainly more capable off road. The Tremor has lower production numbers but I doubt anyone looks at it being unique, it...
Get the one for $38500, you are getting a more vehicle for $1500 less and investing 4.5 hours more of your time. Is your time worth $1500 or $333 an hour?
Kind of like my father's '64 Falcon with the 200ci 6. I remember when it got older and started to burn oil my father would always say "it's old enough to smoke".